Bennett Shellfish offers 2 Lobster Rolls for $30 Everyday!
I recently came across a hidden gem of a place in Montauk and wanted to share it with our readers…Bennett Shellfish. What makes this a hidden gem, is this isn’t your average eatery or seafood store. It’s located in a residential neighborhood in Montauk!
What is Bennett Shellfish?
Bennett Shellfish was started by Kim Esperian and her partner, Clint Bennett, a 14th generation bay man who has been clamming and fishing most of his life. It’s a perfect partnership because Clint loves to fish and clam and Kim loves to meet all the people who come to their shop and even makes some of the seafood they sell.
What Are They Known For?
Bennett Shellfish is known for their fresh seafood, locally harvested shellfish, and baked goods. They believe in water to table and source the best local seafood around. If you love Tuna, make sure to grab some when visiting.
In addition, their Clam Pies are one of their most popular items that sell out almost daily and are made by Kim! They also offer 2 for $30 Lobster Rolls everyday! Yes, I said 2 for $30. Do you see now why I call this place a “hidden gem?”
Where is Bennett Shellfish Located?
Now this isn’t your average storefront. Bennett Shellfish is attached to a home located at 2 South Debusy Road in Montauk. There is a park across the street and a Wishing Well in the front yard. To enter, walk towards the left side of the house to the sign that says “Bennett Shellfish.”
*The Wishing Well: This well was built at night with stones that glowed on the beach under the moonlight. Legend has it, if you wish on this Well at night under a full moon with only love in your heart, you wish may come true!
Things To Know Before Visiting
Next time you’re in Montauk, head to this hidden local gem and score yourself a delicious Lobster Roll, or 2, at an affordable price! Bennett Shellfish is open everyday 11am-8pm and is located at 2 South Debusy Road in Montauk (look for the wishing well!). They accept CASH ONLY, so make sure to stop at the ATM to be able to try their Clam Pies and Lobster Rolls! For more information, click HERE!
For more article about EATS on Long Island, click HERE!
Photo Credit: Photos on this article were sourced from Bennett Shellfish Instagram. Follow them HERE!