A New All-Day Café Experience Takes Over a Familiar Space
Huntington Village has officially welcomed a fresh new addition to its dining scene, as Mighty Fine opens its doors at the former Finley’s location on Green Street. With a focus on elevated comfort food, handcrafted pies, and a warm, community-driven atmosphere, this all-day café is already generating buzz. From dog-friendly outdoor seating to a soon-to-open backyard beer garden, Mighty Fine is poised to become a go-to gathering spot for locals looking to relax, indulge, and try something new.
A Fresh Chapter at a Familiar Address
Located at 43 Green Street in Huntington, Mighty Fine breathes new life into a space long known to the community. Owner and entrepreneur Daria Lamb, who many may recognize from her successful ventures Book Mark Café and Page Two Bakery in Oyster Bay, is stepping back into the hospitality scene with a concept that blends comfort, creativity, and connection.
Her vision is simple yet ambitious: to elevate not just pie, but the entire café experience. With a welcoming environment designed for everything from morning coffee to evening wine, Mighty Fine invites guests to slow down and savor every moment.
Elevated Comfort Food with a Creative Twist
At the heart of Mighty Fine’s menu is a thoughtful take on comfort food classics. Guests can expect dishes that feel familiar but are elevated with quality ingredients and creative flair.
Menu highlights include:
- Filet mignon pot pie
- Unique, chef-driven sandwiches
- Fresh salads and house-made biscuits
- A variety of sweet and savory pies
Whether dining in or taking food to-go, the menu is designed to satisfy a wide range of cravings, with vegan and vegetarian options ensuring there’s something for everyone.
A Pie Experience Like No Other
What truly sets Mighty Fine apart is its dedication to reinventing America’s relationship with pie. Guests can even take part in a one-of-a-kind “design your own fruit pie” experience, where their custom creation is baked fresh and ready in about an hour.
From classic favorites to inventive new flavors, every pie is made from scratch, reinforcing the café’s commitment to quality and craftsmanship.
Cocktails, Community, and Outdoor Charm
Mighty Fine isn’t just about the food—it’s about the full experience. Guests can enjoy a curated selection of beer, wine, and creative cocktails designed to complement the menu and encourage relaxation.
The outdoor space is another standout feature:
- A dog-friendly front yard perfect for casual visits
- A beautiful backyard beer garden set to open in May
- A family-friendly environment ideal for gatherings
Adding to the charm, Mighty Fine is collaborating with the adjacent “Published” bookstore, further strengthening its ties to the local community and creating a unique cultural hub in the heart of Huntington.
Grand Opening Celebration You Don’t Want to Miss
Mighty Fine is kicking things off with a multi-day grand opening celebration from Sunday, April 26 through Tuesday, April 28.
Sunday, April 26:
- Live music from Castle Hill Acoustic (1–4 PM)
- Apple Pie Moonshine tasting (3–5 PM)
- 20% off food, pies, and drinks all day
- Gift certificates and prizes throughout the day
Monday & Tuesday, April 27–28:
- Buy an entrée, get a free cookie or brownie
- Half-price wine, beer, and cocktails
- More chances to win prizes and gift certificates
A New Local Favorite in the Making
Open daily from 8 AM to 8 PM, Mighty Fine is more than just a restaurant—it’s a place where the community can come together over great food, thoughtful drinks, and a shared appreciation for quality.
With its creative menu, welcoming atmosphere, and commitment to doing things differently, Mighty Fine is already shaping up to be a must-visit destination in Huntington.
Give Mighty Fine a Try!
If you’re looking for your next favorite local spot, it’s time to head to Green Street and see what all the excitement is about. Whether you’re stopping in for a custom pie, a craft cocktail, or a relaxing afternoon in the garden, Mighty Fine delivers an experience that lives up to its name.
Make plans to visit, bring your friends (and your dog), and discover why Huntington’s newest addition is already making a mighty fine impression.
Published Officially Opens in Huntington Village
