Where Love Is Always on the Menu
Valentine’s Day on Long Island is the perfect excuse to slow down, dress up, and enjoy an intimate evening over an unforgettable meal. From candlelit dining rooms and classic steakhouses to refined bistros and waterfront views enjoyed from inside, Long Island is filled with restaurants that know how to set the mood. Whether couples are celebrating a new romance or a lifetime together, these romantic dining destinations in Suffolk and Nassau County provide the perfect setting. With Valentine’s Day being one of the busiest dining nights of the year, reservations are highly recommended—and booking early is essential.
Romantic Restaurants in Suffolk County
Barrotta’s Supper Club – Huntington
Old-school glamour meets modern Italian-American cuisine at Barrotta’s Supper Club. With velvet booths, vintage décor, and live jazz music, this Huntington favorite delivers classic romance. Signature dishes like Beef Wellington, lobster ravioli, and crab cakes make it a top choice for Valentine’s Day. Pre-fixe menus are common on weekends, so early reservations are strongly advised.
The LakeHouse – Bay Shore
Offering stunning views of the Great South Bay from its elegant interior, The LakeHouse combines refined New American cuisine with a warm, upscale atmosphere. It’s a popular destination for Valentine’s Day celebrations, making advance reservations a must.
Arlo Kitchen & Bar – Northport (Fort Salonga)
Arlo Kitchen & Bar delivers understated elegance with its multi-level dining rooms, open kitchen, and impressive wine list. Featuring locally sourced seafood, prime steaks, and fresh pasta, Arlo strikes the perfect balance between sophistication and comfort—ideal for a romantic evening.
eatMOSAIC – St. James
For couples who enjoy a truly intimate and curated dining experience, eatMOSAIC stands out. Known for its ever-changing five-course tasting menu, this cozy St. James restaurant showcases seasonal ingredients and inventive flavors. Seating is limited, making early booking essential for Valentine’s Day.
Mill Pond Steak & Seafood – Centerport
Set along the scenic waterfront, Mill Pond Steak & Seafood offers premium steaks, fresh seafood, sushi, and a raw bar in a romantic indoor setting. Its elegant atmosphere and reputation for special-occasion dining make it a popular Valentine’s Day choice.
The James – Babylon
Located in the beautifully restored Babylon Carriage House, The James offers a modern brasserie experience with an upscale feel. Known for dry-aged steaks, fresh seafood, and an extensive wine list, it’s a great option for couples looking to celebrate Valentine’s Day in style.
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar – Huntington
Prime is widely considered one of Long Island’s most romantic restaurants. With breathtaking water views enjoyed from its sophisticated dining room and a refined menu, it’s a favorite for anniversaries, date nights, and proposals. Valentine’s reservations book up quickly.
George Martin Strip Steak – Great River
This Art Deco-style steakhouse offers an intimate, classic dining experience in a historic setting. Known for its dry-aged steaks, chops, and seafood, along with live music on weekends, George Martin Strip Steak is a timeless Valentine’s Day destination.
Chops Steakhouse – Patchogue
With its prohibition-era speakeasy vibe, Chops Steakhouse delivers drama, elegance, and romance. Dry-aged steaks, fresh seafood, craft cocktails, and decadent desserts make it ideal for a memorable Valentine’s dinner. Reservations are highly recommended.
Romantic Restaurants in Nassau County
Maldon & Mignonette – Sea Cliff
This charming American bistro offers a cozy, intimate setting perfect for Valentine’s Day. Known for its seasonal menu and rustic yet refined flavors, Maldon & Mignonette is a favorite for couples seeking a quieter, more romantic evening.
LOLA – Great Neck
LOLA blends Mediterranean flavors with a modern, elegant atmosphere. Creative small plates, beautifully presented entrées, and an extensive wine list make it a standout choice for couples looking for a sophisticated Valentine’s celebration.
Volpe Ristorante – Woodbury
Located within the Fox Hollow estate, Volpe Ristorante offers fine Italian dining in a romantic setting. With classic dishes, live music on weekends, and an elegant ambiance, it’s a wonderful option for a Valentine’s Day date.
Felice – Roslyn
Felice brings Tuscan-inspired warmth to Roslyn with an inviting dining room overlooking Roslyn Pond. Italian classics, shareable plates, and a thoughtfully curated wine list create a cozy yet elevated Valentine’s Day experience.
Felicia Restaurant & Bar – Long Beach
Chic and intimate, Felicia Restaurant & Bar is known for its small plates, fine wines, and craft cocktails. The stylish indoor setting makes it a great option for couples who enjoy sharing dishes and savoring a relaxed, romantic evening.
Red Salt Room by David Burke – Garden City
Located inside the Garden City Hotel, Red Salt Room offers a luxurious dining experience ideal for Valentine’s Day. Signature dishes like candied bacon on a clothesline and Himalayan salt–aged steaks pair perfectly with the elegant atmosphere.
Sage Bistro Moderne – Woodbury
Sage Bistro Moderne combines classic cuisine with modern elegance. Featuring dishes like French onion soup and seafood bouillabaisse, Sage Bistro Moderne offers a refined yet welcoming environment for a romantic Valentine’s dinner.
L’Etoile – Oyster Bay
Located in the historic Snouder’s building, L’Etoile brings Parisian bistro charm to Oyster Bay. Traditional French cuisine, an all-French wine list, and a sophisticated dining room make it a timeless choice for Valentine’s Day.
A Romantics Valentine’s Day to Remember
From candlelit dining rooms to indulgent tasting menus and classic fine dining, Long Island offers countless romantic restaurants perfect for Valentine’s Day. With February 14th fast approaching—and many of these spots offering limited seating or special menus—couples are encouraged to book reservations early to secure the perfect table and enjoy a truly memorable evening.
Looking for Out-of-the-Box Idea’s for Valentine’s Day? Click HERE!
