The Best Restaurants in Farmingdale to Try this Fall

With Google Ratings of 4.3 and Higher, Here are The Best Restaurants in Farmingdale to Try

Farmingdale, NY, has quickly become a vibrant dining destination, offering a diverse array of restaurants that cater to every palate. From Italian delicacies to modern American fare, this Long Island town is home to some of the finest eateries around. Here’s a look at the Best Restaurants in Farmingdale to try this fall that locals and visitors alike rave about.

The Best Restaurants in Farmingdale to Try This Fall!

Harley’s American Grille (4.3 Google Rating)

For those looking for hearty American fare, Harley’s American Grille delivers. With its relaxed vibe and menu packed with comfort food classics, this is the perfect spot for enjoying burgers, steaks, and a range of delicious appetizers. Their craft beer selection is also top-notch, making it a great hangout for locals.

317 Main Street (4.4 Google Rating)

Located in the heart of Farmingdale, 317 Main Street is known for its eclectic menu and inviting atmosphere. Offering everything from burgers and BBQ to Southern-inspired dishes, this family-friendly spot is perfect for both casual dinners and special occasions. Their Take-Out Family Packages are also a hit, providing great meals at affordable prices.

Whiskey Down Diner (4.5 Google Rating)

A modern twist on the classic diner, Whiskey Down Diner blends comfort food with innovative cocktails in a stylish setting. From creative breakfast dishes to inventive entrees, this spot stands out for its menu variety. It’s an excellent place to meet friends for brunch or unwind after a long day with a whiskey-based cocktail.

Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar (4.5 Google Rating)

Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar offers an upscale take on traditional Italian cuisine with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients. Known for its elegant decor and warm ambiance, Vespa is the perfect spot for a date night or a special occasion. Their menu ranges from wood-fired pizzas to handcrafted pastas, all made with an artisanal touch.

The Villager (4.5 Google Rating)

The Villager is a trendy gastropub that blends the best of casual dining with a lively bar scene. Offering craft beers, elevated bar bites, and creative takes on comfort food, The Villager is a popular choice for both lunch and dinner. Their laid-back atmosphere and rotating specials make it a go-to spot in the Farmingdale area.

Nunzi’s (4.5 Google Rating)

For a more upscale dining experience, Nunzi’s is the place to be. This Italian-American restaurant has garnered a reputation for its exceptional service and expertly crafted dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for house-made pasta, fresh seafood, or tender steaks, Nunzi’s delivers on all fronts. The sophisticated atmosphere makes it ideal for special celebrations.

Palmer’s American Grille (4.5 Google Rating)

A staple in Farmingdale for years, Palmer’s American Grille offers a blend of fine dining and comfortable ambiance. Their diverse menu ranges from fresh seafood and steak to pasta and salads, all prepared with the freshest ingredients. Known for its welcoming service and beautifully presented dishes, Palmer’s is a classic choice for a refined dining experience.

Vico (4.6 Google Rating)

Bringing the flavors of the Amalfi Coast to Farmingdale, Vico offers a culinary experience that is both authentic and memorable. Known for its handmade pasta, fresh ingredients, and commitment to traditional Italian cooking, Vico has a dedicated following. Their family takeout special is a local favorite, providing an excellent deal for a delicious Italian meal.

Casa Stellina Ristorante (4.7 Google Rating)

Casa Stellina Ristorante is a cozy Italian spot that has earned a loyal following for its homey atmosphere and authentic dishes. With a focus on traditional Italian recipes passed down through generations, this restaurant offers everything from rich pastas to flavorful seafood dishes. The intimate setting makes it perfect for a quiet, relaxing meal.

Honorable Mentions of Best Restaurants in Farmingdale

In addition to the restaurants above, Farmingdale has even more to offer for food lovers. Tre Scalini is a popular Italian restaurant amongst locals and spots like My Grandmother’s Kitchen and Library Cafe provide lively atmospheres for casual eats and drinks. In addition, Lithology Brewing is a great spot to pop in after your meal for a local brew!

The Best Restaurants to Try in Farmingdale

Whether you’re in the mood for Italian cuisine, modern American dishes, or a cozy diner experience, Farmingdale has a restaurant to suit every craving. Each of these standout spots brings something unique to the table, making the town a must-visit for food enthusiasts. Support local and add these restaurants in Farmingdale to your “must try” list!

For more articles about places to EAT on Long Island, click HERE!

To read more about Lithology, click HERE!

Google ratings were taken on 9/14/2024

Photo Credit: Photos in this article were sourced from the business instagram account

Melissa Farrell CEO

Melissa Farrell has a mission to support local business by "Going Local." As a local business owner herself, she understands the struggles entrepreneurs face when owning a business and is always trying to find ways to shine a spotlight onto them. Melissa started Going Local Tours & Experiences back in 2020 during the pandemic in hopes to bring people back into local restaurants and shops. She created food tours in Huntington, NY that would stop at 3-4 local businesses and gave the guests the chance to meet the owner and hear the story behind the business. She soon realized how powerful storytelling is when connecting people to local businesses and created options with local store owners as well to bring them onto the tour to share their story. Melissa wanted to expand out of Huntington to be able to support even more local businesses and started creating luxury picnics where she would bring local to you! She would find local businesses in the area of the picnic set up and deliver it to you offering ways to support over 3 local businesses at each picnic. This wasn't enough. She wanted to find a better way to help spread awareness of local businesses and share their stories. Enter Evangeline Knell...a woman with over 30 years of broadcasting experience who somehow convinced Melissa to host a 3 day live stream from the Huntington Fall Festival. She had never been on camera before, but working alongside Evie to create the 3 shows, gave Melissa the confidence to take on the challenge. The 3 shows produced focused on the local vendors, the food trucks and the events that occurred at the festival and had a much larger reach than Melissa could ever of done on her own. They soon realized a business partnership was needed and combined their two businesses, Identity Digital which is a production company and Going Local Tours and Experiences to form Going Local Media. Evie and Melissa even formed their own distribution outlet by creating Going Local TV, a streaming platform like Netflix or YouTube, that is all about local businesses, events and organizations on Long Island. There are over 200 videos including their podcast series "Let's Get Local" "Long Island Business Minds" and "Local Business Spotlight" that help spread awareness of our local businesses and Long Island Professionals. They are always thinking up new ways to support local, including this site, Going Local Long Island is a directory of articles on how to Go Local on Long Island. We appreciate you taking the time to read this and for supporting local! Thank you!

See Full Bio