Where to Celebrate the Most Festive Night of the Year
Christmas Eve is one of the most celebrated dining nights of the year on Long Island—and reservations fill up faster than ever. Whether you’re craving a traditional Italian feast, a fresh seafood spread, or an elevated American dining experience, Long Island’s vibrant restaurant scene offers endless ways to enjoy the holiday without lifting a finger in the kitchen. Below is a curated list of some of the best Restaurants Open Christmas Eve across Suffolk and Nassau Counties, offering everything from cozy neighborhood eateries to high-end holiday destinations.
Make your reservations as soon as possible—tables book quickly, and many of these beloved spots sell out well before December arrives.
NOTE: Restaurants sourced from OpenTable at time of publication.
Restaurants Open Christmas Eve in Suffolk County
Italian Favorites
Osteria Umbra (Smithtown) – Rustic Italian elegance with refined holiday-worthy plates.
Pietro Cucina (St. James) – Classic Italian comfort in a warm, family-friendly setting.
Primi Italian Steakhouse (West Islip) – A luxurious blend of Italian cuisine and premium cuts.
Cirellas (Melville) – A welcoming Italian eatery perfect for traditional Christmas Eve flavors.
Stella Trattoria & Bar (Blue Point) – Modern Italian in a stylish coastal setting.
ITA Kitchen (Patchogue) – Trendy Italian dining with crowd-pleasing favorites.
Seafood & Steakhouses
View (Oakdale) – Contemporary American dining with serene waterfront views.
H2O (Smithtown) – A seafood standout known for fresh catches and elegant dishes.
Harbor Mist (Cold Spring Harbor) – A long-loved destination for seafood and holiday ambiance.
Chops Steakhouse (Patchogue) – Upscale steakhouse dining perfect for a festive night out.
Tellers: An American Chophouse (Islip) – A sophisticated steakhouse in a historic bank building.
American & Global Cuisine
The Lakehouse (Bay Shore) – New American cuisine in a beautiful lakeside space.
Bliss (East Seatuket) – Elevated American dishes with a seasonal approach.
The Halston (Melville) – Modern American dining with metropolitan flair.
Harbor House (Northport) – Cozy and inviting, ideal for a relaxed celebration.
Bistro 44 (Northport) – A polished bistro serving contemporary American fare.
SYMI (Northport) – Flavorful, authentic Greek cuisine.
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar (Huntington) – Upscale waterfront dining with an iconic holiday feel.
Bistro Cassis (Huntington) – Charming French bistro classics in the heart of the village.
Kahani (Huntington) – Elevated Indian cuisine perfect for a unique holiday experience.
The Stone Goat (St. James) – Creative American cuisine with warm hospitality.
Restaurants Open Christmas Eve in Nassau County
Italian Classics
Gioia (Oyster Bay) – Refined Italian plates with a festive atmosphere.
Volpe Ristorante at Fox Hollow (Woodbury) – Upscale Italian dining in a stunning setting.
Stresa Restaurant (Manhasset) – A beloved destination for traditional Italian cuisine.
Cassariano Italian Eatery (Mineola) – Rustic Italian flavors and welcoming hospitality.
ITA Kitchen (Garden City) – Popular Italian spot bringing bold flavors to Nassau.
Uncle Baccala’s (New Hyde Park) – Classic Italian comfort dishes perfect for Christmas Eve.
Seventh Street Cafe (Garden City) – A cozy Italian café offering festive holiday dining — perfect for a warm, welcoming Christmas Eve meal.
Steakhouses & Seafood
Bryant & Cooper (Roslyn) – One of Long Island’s premier steakhouses.
Louie’s Prime Steaks & Seafood (Port Washington) – A treasured waterfront staple.
The Capital Grille (Garden City) – A timeless steakhouse experience for a luxurious holiday dinner.
American & Contemporary Cuisine
Brasserie by Chef Aless (Massapequa) – French-inspired cuisine in a stylish setting.
Market Bistro (Jericho) – Contemporary American dishes with seasonal touches.
2 Spring (Oyster Bay) – A chic and innovative restaurant perfect for special occasions.
West End Café (Carle Place) – Long Island favorite known for warm service and creative menus.
City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill (Westbury) – A lively option with an extensive wine selection.
Plado (Glen Cove) – Tapas and small plates ideal for sharing and celebrating.
Skara Taverna (Williston Park) – Fresh, authentic Greek flavors.
The Marker (Glen Cove) – American cuisine with a modern twist.
Bluebird Kitchen (Merrick) – Contemporary American plates in a refined yet welcoming environment.
Juniper (Westbury) – A modern American menu with inventive offerings.
Book These Restaurants Open Christmas Eve ASAP!
Long Island shines during the holiday season, and these restaurants offer some of the best Christmas Eve dining the region has to offer. Whether you’re looking for an elegant multi-course meal, a cozy neighborhood dinner, or something new and globally inspired, there’s a perfect spot waiting to welcome you.
But don’t wait—Christmas Eve reservations book up incredibly fast. Secure your table now and ensure your holiday celebration is as magical (and delicious) as possible.
