From lobster rolls to seafood boils, these local gems are reeling in rave reviews across Nassau and Suffolk Counties.
Summer on Long Island means more than just beach days and sunshine — it’s peak season for indulging in the freshest seafood the island has to offer. Whether you’re craving Blue Point oysters, baked clams, or a waterfront lobster dinner, Long Island is home to a wide variety of locally owned restaurants ready to satisfy your seafood cravings. Below, we’ve rounded up the top Seafood Restaurants in Nassau and Suffolk counties — each with its own specialty and a loyal local following. Let’s dive in.
*Supporting these local businesses not only ensures a memorable dining experience but helps sustain the vibrant coastal communities that make Long Island unique.
Best Seafood Restaurants in Suffolk County
Varney’s – Brookhaven
📍 2109 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven | ⭐ 4.6
Since 1981, Varney’s has been a beloved staple in Brookhaven. Known for its traditional New England fare, this family-run spot is the place to go for baked clams and lobster rolls in a cozy, coastal setting.
Sandbar – Cold Spring Harbor
📍 55 Main St, Cold Spring Harbor | ⭐ 4.5
A refined take on tavern classics, Sandbar offers elegant seafood dishes curated by Chef Guy Reuge. The raw bar and scallops are standout items, perfect for those seeking a polished yet approachable seafood dining experience.
Jerry & The Mermaid – Riverhead
📍 469 E Main St, Riverhead | ⭐ 4.5
A local institution since 1994, Jerry & The Mermaid serves up fresh clams, mussels, and oysters with a side of warm hospitality. It’s a great stop before or after exploring the North Fork.
Nicky’s Clam Bar – Bay Shore
📍 99 Maple Ave, Bay Shore | ⭐ 4.4
Right near the Fire Island ferry, Nicky’s is a longtime favorite with both locals and summer visitors. Their baked clams and steamers are legendary, and the casual, marina-side vibe can’t be beat.
The Cull House – Sayville
📍 75 Terry St, Sayville | ⭐ 4.4
Known for its broiled fisherman’s platter and Long Island crab cakes, The Cull House is all about ocean-fresh ingredients served in a welcoming atmosphere.
Salt & Barrel – Bay Shore
📍 61 W Main St, Bay Shore | ⭐ 4.4
A destination for oyster lovers, Salt & Barrel is as chic as it is flavorful. Their rotating oyster selection and creative seafood dishes shine in both the speakeasy-style bar and elegant dining room.
The Snapper Inn – Oakdale
📍 500 Shore Dr, Oakdale | ⭐ 4.4
With sweeping views of the Connetquot River and a heritage dating back to 1929, The Snapper Inn offers fine dining with dishes like Horseradish Oreganata Crusted Salmon and daily Long Island fish specials.
The Oar Steak & Seafood Grille– Patchogue
📍 264 West Ave, Patchogue | ⭐ 4.4
Dock your boat and dig into dishes like mussels and pan-seared Chilean sea bass. The Oar’s riverside setting and diverse menu make it perfect for any occasion.
Captain Bill’s – Bay Shore
📍 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore | ⭐ 4.4
A waterfront staple with views and vibes, Captain Bill’s is known for their sautéed flounder and fresh Maine lobster pulled right from the tank.
Fat Fish – Bay Shore
📍 28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore | ⭐ 4.3
Offering Mediterranean-inspired cuisine with live music and bay views, Fat Fish’s lobster risotto and halibut are just as impressive as the scenery.
Best Seafood Restaurants in Nassau County
Hook & Reel – Hicksville
📍 363 Broadway Mall, Hicksville | ⭐ 4.7
Craving a messy, delicious seafood boil? Hook & Reel brings Southern-style feasting to Long Island, known for bold flavors and generous portions.
Schultzy’s Restaurant – Bayville
📍 265 Bayville Ave, Bayville | ⭐ 4.7
Fresh lobster rolls, grilled octopus, and iconic clam bakes make Schultzy’s a can’t-miss destination for seafood lovers seeking a taste of the coast.
Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams – Rockville Centre
📍 79 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre | ⭐ 4.7
A Long Island institution since 1939, Bigelow’s is your go-to for fried clams and classic lobster rolls. Unassuming, nostalgic, and always delicious.
Popei’s – Levittown
📍 384 N Wantagh Ave, Levittown | ⭐ 4.6
Celebrating over 30 years, Popei’s is famous for its hearty portions and award-winning seafood — including crab legs, calamari, and baby back ribs for the surf & turf fans.
Nautilus Café – Freeport
📍 46 Woodcleft Ave, Freeport | ⭐ 4.6
Located on Freeport’s Nautical Mile, Nautilus Café serves up high-end seafood like pecan-crusted orange roughy and broiled scallops with a side of exceptional service.
Off the Hook – Freeport
📍 195A Woodcleft Ave, Freeport | ⭐ 4.5
Laid-back vibes meet quality ingredients at Off the Hook. Known for their double meat lobster rolls and grilled whole branzino, this is the spot for fresh, flavorful seafood and live music.
Vincent’s Clam Bar – Carle Place
📍 179 Old Country Rd, Carle Place | ⭐ 4.5
A Little Italy favorite right in Nassau, Vincent’s blends red-sauce classics with seafood excellence. Try the Lobster Kiss or Snapper Abruzzese.
Jordan Lobster Farms – Island Park
📍 1 Pettit Pl, Island Park | ⭐ 4.5
With over 30 years of history, Jordan’s is both a restaurant and fish market. Their lobster dinners and daily catch are legendary among locals.
Sexy Crab Cajun Seafood & Bar – Levittown
📍 3345 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown | ⭐ 4.5
Looking for all-you-can-eat Cajun seafood? Sexy Crab serves up fun, flavor, and unbeatable value in a lively, casual setting.
Check Out These Seafood Restaurants on Long Island this Summer!
Whether you’re sipping wine by the marina or cracking crab legs with friends, Long Island’s seafood scene has something for everyone. These local favorites are more than just Seafood Restaurants — they’re part of the island’s coastal identity, serving fresh catches and good times for generations.
So this summer, skip the chains and support the hometown heroes that keep our plates full and our communities thriving. Long Island is your oyster — now go eat it.
Don’t forget to share this story on social media to help spread awareness of our local restaurants!
