From classic diners to upscale eats, these local gems are serving up the ultimate weekend indulgence
Brunch is more than just a meal—it’s a ritual. A time to linger over coffee, savor sweet and savory bites, and toast to the weekend with a mimosa (or two). Brunch in Islip should be on the top of your to do list whether you’re craving a cozy diner spread or an elegant experience with craft cocktails and refined fare. Below you will find the Best Spots for Brunch in Islip (in no particular order).
Bayberry
📍 501 Main St, Islip, NY
⏰ Brunch: Saturday & Sunday, 11 AM – 3 PM
Bayberry offers a modern, stylish setting paired with a menu full of creative takes on brunch staples. Their standout dishes include Challah Stuffed French Toast with sweet mascarpone and strawberries, a crave-worthy Fried Chicken & Waffles with spicy honey, and the fan-favorite Bayberry Benedict topped with avocado and applewood smoked bacon.
Vegetarians will love the Vegetable Frittata, while adventurous eaters might want to try their Lemon-Blueberry Dutch Baby Pancake. The Bubbly Board for two is the perfect companion for a celebratory brunch date.
Tellers: An American Chophouse
📍 605 Main St, Islip, NY
⏰ Brunch: Every Sunday, 12 PM – 3 PM
Elegance and indulgence meet at Tellers’ Legacy Brunch, a Sunday-only affair designed to impress. Begin with a complimentary cinnamon roll before diving into decadent dishes like Lobster Huevos Rancheros, Crab Benedict with housemade tater tots, or Short Rib & Eggs topped with horseradish cream.
Classic brunch lovers will appreciate the traditional eggs and omelet selections, while those seeking comfort food can’t go wrong with their Sausage Gravy & Biscuits. Set in a converted bank building with grand decor, Tellers offers a brunch that feels like a special occasion every time.
Jackson Hall American Bar & Grill
📍 335 E Main St, East Islip, NY
⏰ Brunch: Every Sunday starting at 10:30 AM
Jackson Hall serves up classic diner-style with a laid-back neighborhood vibe. French toast, Belgian waffles, and fluffy pancakes are just the beginning. Their stuffed French toast with cream cheese and fresh strawberries is a standout, and guests can build their own omelets to customize the perfect bite.
Affordable cocktails like $4 mimosas and $5 Bloody Marys make this a go-to for groups and casual Sunday gatherings. Don’t miss their Lobster Rolls with 8 different options!
Americano Pie Bar
📍 517 Main St, Islip, NY
⏰ Brunch: Saturday & Sunday, 11 AM – 3 PM
Americano is a stylish spot that brings bold flavors and upscale flair to the brunch table. The Breakfast Pizza with scrambled eggs, sausage, and crispy grandma crust is a must-try, while the Salmon Latke and Prosciutto Croissant offer unique and savory options.
Sweet tooth? Indulge in Almond Crusted French Toast Stix with peanut butter and Nutella or the Banana Foster French Toast. With options ranging from Steak & Eggs over vegetable fried rice to a spicy Breakfast Burrito, Americano knows how to do brunch right.
Oconee Diner
📍 749 Montauk Hwy, Islip, NY
⏰ Brunch: Daily
A staple in the community, Oconee Diner offers daily brunch comfort with a side of hospitality. With over 15 omelet options, griddle classics, and rotating breakfast specials Monday through Thursday, it’s the perfect spot for both early risers and brunch traditionalists.
Owned and operated by a family with over 50 years in the restaurant business, every guest is welcomed like one of their own. Come for the fluffy pancakes, stay for the heartfelt service.
Your Weekend Plans? Brunch in Islip!
No matter what kind of brunch experience you’re after—elevated and elegant or classic and comforting—Islip has you covered. These beloved local spots deliver the flavors, vibes, and hospitality that make brunch the highlight of any weekend. Grab your friends, your family, or treat yourself to a solo outing—just don’t forget to come hungry.
Ready to brunch in Islip? Your table is waiting. 🥂
