Top 10 Spots for Egg Sandwiches in Huntington
Few things spark a passionate discussion in Long Island communities quite like food, and recently, a simple question—“Where can I find the best Egg Sandwiches in Huntington?”—led to an overwhelming 195+ comments on the Huntington Matters Community Page.
Egg sandwiches are a staple of Long Island, and in Huntington, there’s no shortage of great spots serving up this classic. From traditional delis to cozy bakeries, here are the top 10 places for egg sandwiches, as voted by the community.
The Best Egg Sandwiches in Huntington
1. Bay Deli
📍 94 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743
Coming in at #1, Bay Deli takes pride in doing things the old-fashioned way. Here, eggs are cracked fresh to order—never from a carton or cooked in a microwave. Whether you like them fried, scrambled, over easy, or well-done, they’ll make your sandwich exactly how you want it. Bay Deli has been perfecting this craft for over 50 years, making it a beloved breakfast destination.
2. Woodbury Deli
📍 153 Woodbury Rd, Woodbury, NY 11797
Even though it’s just outside of Huntington, Woodbury Deli is worth the drive. This neighborhood favorite has been serving up breakfast staples since 1983, earning a loyal following for their hearty, made-to-order egg sandwiches.
3. Hometown Bake Shop
📍 2 Little Neck Rd, Centerport, NY 11721
Known for their homemade, from-scratch approach, Hometown Bake Shop ranks high on the list. Every sandwich is made with fresh, natural ingredients, and they offer gluten-free options, making this a great stop for those with dietary restrictions.
4. Teresa’s Lunch Box
📍 758 Park Ave, Huntington, NY 11743
More than just a deli, Teresa’s Lunch Box is known for its wide assortment of breakfast and lunch options. Their classic bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich is a local favorite, made with fresh ingredients and served with a welcoming neighborhood vibe.
5. Kerber’s Farm
📍 309 W Pulaski Rd, Huntington, NY 11743
A Huntington landmark, Kerber’s Farm has been serving the community since 1941. Originally a poultry farm, it has evolved into a charming farm stand offering fresh eggs, baked goods, and delicious breakfast sandwiches. If you want a taste of local history with your egg sandwich, this is the place to go.
6. Southdown Coffee
📍 210-B Wall St, Huntington, NY 11743
Best known for their high-quality coffee, Southdown Coffee also serves up one of the best egg sandwiches in town. Their freshly baked pastries and carefully sourced ingredients make for a great start to any morning. Plus, they offer vegan and gluten-free options.
7. Cold Spring Plaza Deli
📍 15 Harbor Rd, Cold Spring Harbor, NY 11724
While technically in Cold Spring Harbor, this deli is a short drive away and well worth the trip. Their sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich with home fries is a fan favorite, making them a must-try for breakfast lovers.
8. Sophia’s Place Deli & Grocery
📍 9 Semon Rd, Huntington, NY 11743
A hidden gem, Sophia’s Place is a small deli near “The Big H” that serves up big flavors. Customers love the friendly service and consistently delicious egg sandwiches.
9. Stella Blue Bistro
📍 188 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743
Run by Rob and Ann Koopman, Stella Blue Bistro brings great food and Grateful Dead vibes to Huntington. Their breakfast sandwiches are made with love and fresh ingredients, making them a top pick for locals.
10. Danny’s Deli
📍 197 Depot Rd, Huntington Station, NY 11746
Danny’s Deli is a go-to spot for quick, delicious breakfast sandwiches. Whether you’re grabbing something on the go or looking for a classic BEC, this Huntington Station favorite delivers every time.
Where Will You Get Your Next Egg Sandwiches in Huntington?
Huntington has no shortage of amazing egg sandwiches, whether you prefer a classic deli-style B.E.C.S.P.K or something a little more gourmet. If you’re on a mission to find the best, start with this list—you might just find your new favorite breakfast spot!
Where do you get your go-to Egg Sandwich in Huntington? Let us know!
Looking for Brunch Spots in Huntington? Click HERE!