The Best Spots Serving Up Lobster on Long Island

SHARE THIS STORY:

Lobster on Long Island

Summertime is here which means it’s time to enjoy all the food that comes along with it. One of my favorite meals of Summer is having a lobster dinner with all the fixings so I’m writing this article in honor of all my lobster lovers out there. Here are some of the best spots serving up Lobster on Long Island!

Lobster on Long Island

43 Green at Finleys

(Huntington, NY)

5.0 Google rating

43 Green is the newest restaurant to hit the Huntington restaurant scene and is located inside Finley’s of Green Street. On Thursday nights, they offer a Lobster special that includes a 1 1/4 pound steamed Lobster with fresh corn and a baked potato for $26.95!

In addition, on Wednesday’s you can enjoy All You Can Eat Mussels for $18.95 and includes fries and crostini! 43 Green also offers a ton of outdoor seating on their front or back patio and an outside bar open on Fridays and Saturdays. To read more about 43 Green, click HERE!

Popeis

(Deer Park, Bethpage, Coram, NY)

4.3 Google rating *Deer Park location

Popei’s has been a staple for seafood and Lobster on Long Island since the early 80’s and this summer they are not screwing around with their Lobster options! They offer a Whole Lobster, Twin Whole Lobsters, Stuffed Lobster, Overstuffed Lobster, and even a small or large Clam Bake option. For more information and pricing, head to their website HERE!

Sunken Meadow Seafood Fest

(Kings Park, NY)

4.5 Google rating *Pavillion at Sunken Meadow

For those of you looking for more of a “beachy” lobster dinner, head to Sunken Meadow State Park in Kings Park on Wednesday nights from 5pm-sunset. At field 1 on the boardwalk, you’ll find the seafood fest presented by the Lessings Hospitality Group which also features live music. The event is weather permitting and reservations are recommended and can made by calling (631) 269-6850. For more information, click HERE!

Jackson Hall

(East Islip, NY)

4.2 Google rating

If you’re looking for Lobster on Long Island that comes in all forms including a Lobster Bomb, look no further. Jackson Hall in East Islip is home to the Best Lobster Rolls on Long Island, their famous Lobster Bomb, and also offers up Lobster Dinners as well!

Chef Mike Landesberg is all about making his customers happy and offers up live lobsters at $29.95 per pound or stuffed with jumbo crab meat for $36.95 per pound which come with any 2 sides anyday of the week. In addition, give Chef Mike 48 hours notice and he can snag you any size lobster between 2-10lbs!

Jackson Hall is a special place with an amazing chef who loves to pay it forward. Make sure to check out this food review of Jackson Hall by “The Glutton’s Guide” HERE! For more information about Jackson Hall or to make a reservation, click HERE!

Jackson Hall <em>Photo credit Mike Landesberg<em>

Frank’s Steaks

(Rockville Centre, NY)

4.4 Google rating

Frank’s Steaks located in Rockville Centre, has been named “The Best Skirt Steak on Earth” by Zagat and “Best Steakhouse on LI” by the LI Herald. Frank’s doesn’t stop there. They also offer their Annual Summer Lobster Feast which features a 2lb Maine lobster served with choice of Caesar or Frank’s salad and corn on the cob for $70 plus tax and gratuity. Reservations are recommended and can be made through their website HERE!

Lobster on Long Island
Franks Steaks

Jordan’s Lobster Farms

(Island Park, NY)

4.4 Google rating

When you visit Jordan Lobster Farms, you’ll experience the warm feeling of New England’s old world charm. They pride themselves on offering the highest quality seafood and optimal customer service and acts as a restaurant and seafood store.

This summer, they are offering a take out special of Fresh Maine Lobsters 3 for $48 and are 1-1.25lb each. You can have them live or steamed and are only while supplies last. If you prefer to dine at their restaurant, they offer weekly specials on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday incuding 2lb Tuesday/Thursday and Wild Wednesday. See the photo below for more details or visit their website HERE!

The Wantagh Inn

(Wantagh, NY)

4.5 Google rating

The Wantagh Inn opened on December 8th, 1984 and their unique charm has been evolving for the past 38 years.  Their menu is varied, with specials changing daily, including fresh fish & steaks. If you’re looking for Lobster on Long Island, head to the Wantagh Inn on Mondays.

On Monday’s this summer, they are offering up “Lobster Night” for $34 that includes a 1 1/2 lb lobster steamed, boiled, or oreganata style with corn on the cob and baked potato. They are located on Railroad Avenue, just across from the Wantagh train station and for more information, click HERE!

Mack’s

(Babylon, NY)

4.0 Google rating

Opened since April 2023, Mack’s is redefining the dining experience with a unique concept – a full menu offered all day, every day, in true diner-style. The atmosphere at Mack’s is set to be a desired location for brunch enthusiasts and dinner connoisseurs alike and this summer are offering up a Lobster Dinner!

Available all day on Wednesday through Saturday, you can enjoy a 1.25lb steamed lobster with fries or baked potato, corn on the cob and side salad for $26.99. For more information about Mack’s, click HERE!

Lobster on Long Island
Macks in Babylon

Volpe

(Woodbury, NY)

4.4 Google rating

Volpe, situated on Long Island’s elegant Fox Hollow estate, marries old-world recipes with the culinary expertise of the award-winning Scotto brothers, delivering a fine dining experience like no other. Named after the Italian word for fox, Volpe uses only the freshest local produce, seafood, and livestock in crafting both traditional Italian dishes and innovative creations with a twist.

On Wednesday’s from 5pm-9pm, Volpe offers up Lobster Night with outdoor dining and live music (weather permitting). On Lobster Night, your first course is included and offers options such as french onion soup, soup of the day, mussels or salad. For your main course, you’ll choose from a 2lb Lobster ($69), Twin Lobster Tails ($74), Filet Mignon and Lobster Tail ($79-or petite filet for $59), amongst options like Lobster Mac & Cheese ($32) and a Lobster Roll ($36). For more information or to make a reservation, click HERE!

Conclusion

We hope this article helped those looking for Lobster on Long Island and you now have a few new spots to put on your summer bucket list! Make sure to support local this summer wherever you can and let’s keep local alive on Long Island!

Are you a Lobster Roll Lover? Click HERE for the Best Lobster Rolls on Long Island!

For restaurants serving up Outdoor Dining on Long Island, click HERE!

Photo Credit: Photos featured in this article were sourced from the Instagram accounts of the included businesses.

Google ratings are taken at time of publication

[ecs-list-events design="compact" limit="8" timeonly="true" pagination="true" venue="true" thumb="true"]

The Latest From Going Local Long Island